Customer Reviews (100)

Alex • 2025-03-29T04:09:19.814Z

super enjoyable micro management game, sick art. I bought a pack of two to help out the devs cuz this was a break from the gotcha games

Xavuer Cuvellier • 2025-03-28T16:31:33.916Z

played it via apk but was so entranced by the experience I had to buy the game. wonderful game

Mage Mail • 2025-03-28T13:16:02.874Z

It's a pretty good idea, but with my luck, all my monsters die because they just keep spinning around the dungeon instead of fighting the damn boss, it's so frustrating and i dont think theres an in world reason why they spin around the same 6 rooms 3 times before going to the boss its so stupid

Summary of Key Insights

  • Dungeon Maker is a well-received offline dungeon management game with roguelike elements. The game boasts significant replayability, a unique gameplay loop, and a charming art style. However, users report issues with bugs, save data loss, slow progression, and a lack of clear UI explanations. The game enjoys overwhelmingly positive sentiment, indicated by a high percentage of 5-star reviews. The game's offline nature and lack of pay-to-win mechanics are frequently praised.

  • Strengths: Engaging gameplay, high replayability, charming art style, offline play, no pay-to-win elements.

  • Weaknesses: Bugs, save data loss, slow progression, unclear UI, lack of tutorial in story mode, occasional crashes, and some users feel MTX content is too heavily gated.

  • Overall Sentiment: Highly positive, with many users expressing strong enjoyment and appreciation for the game's unique mechanics.

  • Quantitative Metrics:

    • Overall Rating: Appears to be high, based on the strong skew towards 5-star reviews.
    • Score Distribution: 5-star (69%), 4-star (13%), 3-star (6%), 2-star (5%), 1-star (7%). This indicates a very positive reception overall.

Data & Methodology Overview

  • Data Sample Size: 100 reviews
  • Time Frame: Reviews appear to span several years, from the game's initial release to the present (2025 is mentioned in a review).
  • Analysis Methods: Manual sentiment analysis and keyword extraction were used to identify recurring themes, positive aspects, pain points, and feature requests. The star rating distribution was used for quantitative analysis.

Key User Pain Points

  • Bugs and Crashes: Several users report bugs and crashes, including crashes when pulling down the notification bar. This significantly impacts the user experience and can lead to frustration.
  • Save Data Loss: A recurring and serious issue is the loss of save data, sometimes due to cloud save errors. This is particularly frustrating when users have made significant progress or purchased in-app items.
  • Slow Progression: Many users feel that progression is too slow, particularly concerning the acquisition of "devil stones" or gems needed to unlock content.
  • Unclear UI and Tutorial: Some new players find the UI confusing and the lack of a proper tutorial in story mode makes it difficult to understand the game mechanics.
  • Difficulty Spikes/Imbalance: A few users found the difficulty curve to be uneven, with certain levels feeling unfair or requiring excessive grinding.
  • DLC/MTX Gating: Some users feel that too much content is locked behind microtransactions or that the pace of earning in-game currency to acquire this content is too slow.

Frequently Requested Features

  • Updates and New Content: Many users request updates with new content, including new Dark Lords, monsters, traps, and game modes.
  • PC Version: A significant number of users have requested a PC version of the game, ideally on Steam.
  • Portrait Mode: One user has been requesting portrait mode since before 2025.
  • Improved UI/UX: Some users suggest improving the UI for better clarity and a more consistent graphical style.
  • Speed Up Options: Some users would like options to speed up gameplay, especially in the later stages.
  • More Detailed Ability Descriptions: Users have requested more in-depth explanations of in-game abilities and effects.

Strengths and Positive Aspects

  • Engaging Gameplay: Users consistently praise the game's unique and engaging gameplay loop, which combines dungeon management, roguelike elements, and card-based mechanics.
  • High Replayability: The game's diverse content, numerous unlockables, and strategic depth contribute to high replayability.
  • Charming Art Style: The pixel art style is widely appreciated and adds to the game's overall charm.
  • Offline Play: The ability to play the game offline is a major selling point for many users.
  • No Pay-to-Win: Users appreciate that the game is not pay-to-win and that all content can be unlocked through gameplay.
  • Depth and Strategy: The game offers a surprising amount of depth and requires strategic thinking to succeed.
  • Unique Concept: Users enjoy the unique concept of playing as the dungeon lord and defending against heroes.

Prioritized Action Recommendations

High Priority:

  • Address Bugs and Crashes: Investigate and fix the reported bugs and crashes, particularly those related to the notification bar and save data. This directly impacts playability and user satisfaction.
  • Improve Save Data Reliability: Implement robust save data mechanisms and thoroughly test cloud save functionality to prevent data loss. Consider offering multiple save slots.
  • Optimize Progression: Rebalance the game's progression system to make it feel less grindy, especially concerning the acquisition of premium currency.

Medium Priority:

  • Enhance UI/UX: Improve the UI for better clarity and consistency. Consider adding tooltips or more detailed explanations of game mechanics.
  • Add Tutorial for Story Mode: Implement a proper tutorial for story mode to guide new players through the initial stages of the game.
  • Consider a PC Version: Given the recurring requests, explore the feasibility of developing a PC version of the game, possibly for Steam.

Low Priority:

  • Implement Portrait Mode: While requested by one user, assess the demand and technical feasibility of implementing portrait mode.
  • Add Speed Up Options: Consider adding options to speed up gameplay, especially for experienced players.
  • Refine Ability Descriptions: Provide more detailed descriptions of in-game abilities and effects to improve player understanding.

Opportunities for Startup Ideas

  • Dungeon Management Game on PC: The strong demand for a PC version suggests a market opportunity for a more complex and visually rich dungeon management game.
  • Roguelike Game with Asymmetric Multiplayer: A game where one player manages a dungeon while others attempt to raid it as heroes could be a compelling multiplayer experience.
  • Mobile Game Save Data Backup Service: A service that provides reliable and secure cloud save backups for mobile games could address a significant pain point for many players.

Trends and Observations

  • Long-Term Player Base: Many users have been playing the game for several years, indicating a loyal and dedicated player base.
  • Positive Sentiment Despite Issues: Despite the reported issues, the overall sentiment remains highly positive, suggesting that the game's core mechanics are strong enough to overcome these problems.
  • Appreciation for Offline Play: The offline nature of the game is a significant advantage in a market saturated with online-only titles.
  • Multiple Languages: One review is written in Indonesian ("Sangat seru coy"), indicating a potentially global player base.

Conclusion

Dungeon Maker is a successful and well-loved game with a strong core gameplay loop and a dedicated player base. Addressing the reported bugs, save data issues, and progression concerns should be the top priorities. Exploring the possibility of a PC version and implementing UI/UX improvements could further enhance the game's appeal. The game's offline nature and lack of pay-to-win mechanics are key strengths that should be maintained. Overall, the game is highly recommended, but addressing the identified issues will significantly improve the user experience and ensure its continued success.

Original App Link

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.GameCoaster.DungeonMaker