Customer Reviews (500)

972 871 547 • 2025-02-27T20:10:39-07:00

1jbkiu4g0

Cyberia001 • 2025-02-13T07:38:52-07:00

I do NOT care how little it is! WHY IS YOUR GAME CHARGING ME WITHOUT ME BUYING ANYTHING?! Since it is unauthorized that's theft!

Beitbwkleifn • 2025-02-08T14:59:51-07:00

Game is really nice

Summary of Key Insights

  • Immortal Taoists-idle Games receives mixed reviews, with a generally positive sentiment skewed by significant concerns regarding monetization ("pay-to-win"), bugs, and misleading advertising. While the game's concept and idle gameplay are appreciated, these issues detract from the user experience and developer trust. The game's reliance on ads for progression and the aggressive monetization strategies are primary sources of frustration. Lack of clear instructions and a cluttered UI also contribute to a less-than-ideal onboarding experience.
  • Key Strengths: Engaging idle gameplay, interesting cultivation theme, and a decent amount of content.
  • Key Weaknesses: Aggressive monetization (P2W), bugs (especially regarding ads and account issues), misleading advertising, cluttered UI, poor translations, and inadequate tutorials.
  • Overall Sentiment: Mixed, leaning towards positive but with significant negative feedback.
  • Quantitative Metrics:
    • Overall Rating (implied average): Leans positive, but affected by negative reviews.
    • Score Distribution:
      • 5-star: 54.8%
      • 4-star: 16%
      • 3-star: 7%
      • 2-star: 5.6%
      • 1-star: 16.6%

Data & Methodology Overview

  • Data Sample Size: 500 reviews
  • Time Frame: Not explicitly stated, but assumed to be a recent collection of reviews given the version number (1.7.7) and references to recent updates.
  • Analysis Methods:
    • Sentiment analysis (manual assessment based on review content)
    • Keyword extraction (identifying frequently mentioned terms and issues)
    • Thematic analysis (grouping reviews based on common themes and concerns)

Key User Pain Points

  • Pay-to-Win (P2W) Mechanics: The most prevalent complaint. Users feel pressured to spend money to progress at a reasonable pace, making the game unfair and frustrating.
  • Bugs and Glitches: Frequent reports of ads not working, game crashes, account login issues, lost purchases, and inventory bugs. This significantly impacts the user experience and trust.
  • Misleading Advertising: Many users complain that the game's advertisements do not accurately represent the actual gameplay, leading to disappointment and negative reviews. Specifically, users noted the use of art from other IPs.
  • Cluttered UI and Poor Instructions: The game's user interface is often described as cluttered and overwhelming, making it difficult for new players to understand the mechanics and navigate the game. The lack of a comprehensive tutorial exacerbates this issue.
  • Censorship and Chat Issues: Overly aggressive censorship in the chat system prevents normal communication between players.
  • Translation Issues: Poor translations make it difficult to understand game mechanics and story elements.
  • Account Issues: Users are experiencing issues switching to new devices and recovering accounts.

Frequently Requested Features

  • More Male Partners: Specific request to increase the number of male partners available in the game.
  • Player Market: A marketplace where players can buy and sell items.
  • More Interesting Combat: Users want more engaging and less passive combat mechanics.
  • Improved Tutorial: A comprehensive tutorial to explain game mechanics and features.
  • Account Deletion: A feature to delete accounts.
  • Server Transfers: The ability to play with friends on different servers.
  • Offline RPG Mode: An offline mode with RPG elements to test skills.
  • More Customization: More character customization options, including darker skin tones and clothing options.
  • More Ways to Earn Spirit Jade: Provide alternative methods to earn premium currency without paying.
  • More Content for End-Game Players: Add more content for players who have reached the end-game.
  • Private Chat: A private chat function to communicate with friends.

Strengths and Positive Aspects

  • Engaging Idle Gameplay: Many users enjoy the idle gameplay loop and the sense of progression.
  • Interesting Cultivation Theme: The Xianxia/Wuxia theme is appealing to fans of the genre.
  • Decent Amount of Content: The game offers a good amount of content to keep players engaged.
  • Relaxing and Time-Killing: Some users find the game relaxing and a good way to pass the time.
  • Active Community: A helpful and active community on Discord and Reddit.
  • Constant Updates: Users appreciate the frequent updates and new content.

Prioritized Action Recommendations

High Priority:

  • Address Bugs and Glitches: Prioritize fixing the most frequently reported bugs, especially those related to ads, purchases, and account issues. This is critical for improving the user experience and building trust.
  • Re-evaluate Monetization Strategy: Reduce the reliance on P2W mechanics and provide more opportunities for free-to-play players to progress. Consider offering more affordable purchase options and increasing the availability of premium currency through gameplay.
  • Improve Advertising Practices: Ensure that advertisements accurately represent the actual gameplay. Avoid using misleading visuals or imagery from other IPs.
  • Implement a Comprehensive Tutorial: Create a clear and informative tutorial to guide new players through the game's mechanics and features.

Medium Priority:

  • Revamp UI/UX: Redesign the user interface to be less cluttered and more intuitive. Improve navigation and make it easier for players to find information and access features.
  • Improve Translations: Address translation errors and ensure that all text is clear and understandable.
  • Enhance Chat System: Relax the censorship filter and address any issues that prevent players from communicating effectively.
  • Add a Player Market: Implement a player market where players can buy and sell items.

Low Priority:

  • Add More Character Customization Options: Expand character customization options, including darker skin tones and clothing options.
  • Add More Engaging Combat: Explore ways to make combat more engaging and interactive.
  • Add Account Deletion Option: Implement a way to delete accounts.

Opportunities for Startup Ideas

  • Cultivation-Themed Game with Fair Monetization: Develop a similar game with a focus on fair monetization practices and a balanced gameplay experience.
  • Improved Idle Game UI/UX: Create a toolkit or framework for developing more intuitive and user-friendly idle game interfaces.
  • Authentic Xianxia/Wuxia Game Experience: Develop a game that accurately represents the Xianxia/Wuxia genre and avoids misleading advertising.
  • Community-Driven Game Development: Involve the community in the game development process to ensure that the game meets their needs and expectations.

Trends and Observations

  • Language Preferences: Predominantly English reviews, with some reviews in Vietnamese and Spanish.
  • Sentiment Shifts: Reviews suggest that the game has become more P2W over time, leading to a decline in sentiment.
  • Collaboration Interest: The collaboration with Tales of Demons and Gods was a positive driver of sentiment.
  • Device Compatibility: Reports of issues on iPad devices, indicating a need for better device optimization.

Conclusion

Immortal Taoists-idle Games has a solid foundation with its engaging idle gameplay and interesting theme. However, the aggressive monetization, bugs, misleading advertising, and UI issues are holding it back from reaching its full potential. By addressing these issues and focusing on creating a fair and enjoyable experience for all players, the developers can significantly improve the game's reputation and long-term success. The overall recommendation is to prioritize bug fixes, re-evaluate the monetization strategy, and improve communication with the player base.

Original App Link

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/immortal-taoists-idle-games/id1475870720?uo=2