Summary of Key Insights

Haqibat Elmomen is generally well-received, particularly among Shia Muslims, with a high percentage of 5-star ratings. Users appreciate its comprehensive features for daily Islamic practices, including prayer times, Quran reading, and Qibla direction. However, there are recurring issues related to prayer time accuracy, incomplete Adhan on iOS devices, and occasional app crashes. There are also requests for additional features like more Quran reciters, Sahifa Sajjadiya, and improved UI/UX, particularly for iPad users. The app's perceived Shia orientation is a point of contention for a small number of users.

Key Strengths:

• Comprehensive features for Islamic practices.
• High user satisfaction among its target audience.
• Useful for travelers.

Key Weaknesses:

• Prayer time accuracy issues in some locations (North America specifically mentioned).
• Incomplete Adhan on iOS devices.
• Occasional app crashes and UI issues.
• Perceived Shia orientation might deter some users.

Overall Sentiment: Positive Overall Rating: High (based on the score distribution, heavily skewed towards 5 stars)

Quantitative Metrics:

• Total Reviews: 500
• Score Distribution: 1-star (5.8%), 2-star (2.2%), 3-star (3.6%), 4-star (6.2%), 5-star (82.2%)

Data & Methodology Overview

• Data Sample Size: 500 reviews
• Time Frame: Not explicitly stated, but likely covers a significant period given the version number (v8-144) and the references to Ramadan 2023 and Hijri calendar 2019 in the app description.
• Analysis Methods: Manual review of individual comments to identify recurring themes, sentiment, feature requests, and pain points. Quantitative analysis of score distribution to assess overall user satisfaction. Keyword extraction was used to identify frequent terms and topics.

Key User Pain Points

• Inaccurate Prayer Times: Several users, particularly in North America, report inaccurate prayer times. This is a critical issue as it directly impacts the app's core functionality.
• Incomplete Adhan (iOS): Many iOS users report that the Adhan only plays the initial Takbir and then stops, requiring them to open the app to hear the full Adhan.
• App Crashes/Bugs: Users experience app crashes, especially when accessing the Quran section or participating in group recitations (Khatmat). Issues with button presses during initial setup are also reported.
• UI/UX Issues: iPad users report UI scaling issues and layout problems when rotating the device. Difficulty adjusting font sizes and bookmarking Quran verses are also mentioned.
• Notification Issues: Some users report that Adhan notifications are not working reliably, or that they only receive a notification but no sound.
• Qibla Direction Inaccuracy: At least one user mentions that the Qibla direction is not always accurate, especially when traveling.

Frequently Requested Features

• More Quran Reciters: Users want a wider selection of Quran reciters, including famous ones like Abdul Basit and Aba Dhar Al-Ghafari.
• Sahifa Sajjadiya: Inclusion of Sahifa Sajjadiya (a collection of prayers attributed to Imam Ali ibn Husayn) is a recurring request.
• Full Adhan Sound on iOS: iOS users consistently request that the Adhan play fully, even when the app is in the background or the screen is locked.
• Offline Quran Audio: Users desire the ability to download Quran audio for offline listening, especially for elderly users.
• More Duas and Ziyarat: Users want a broader range of Duas (supplications) and Ziyarat (pilgrimages) related to Ahlul Bayt.
• Improved Quran Navigation: Some users want a single page view for Quran reading instead of verse-by-verse.
• Home Screen Widget Improvements: Users want the ability to view prayer times on the home screen without opening the app.
• Dark Theme Improvements: Users are requesting a dark theme for the widget.
• Inclusion of Tafsir (Quranic Exegesis): Several users have requested that the app include a reliable Tafsir.

Strengths and Positive Aspects

• Comprehensive Islamic Features: Users appreciate the app's all-in-one nature, providing prayer times, Quran, Duas, Qibla direction, and more.
• Accurate Prayer Times (Generally): Many users find the prayer times to be accurate and helpful, especially when traveling.
• Quran Features: The Quran section is praised for its translation, search functionality, and bookmarking capabilities.
• User-Friendly Interface: Many users find the app easy to use and navigate (although some suggest improvements).
• Helpful for Daily Practices: Users report that the app helps them stay on top of their prayers and other daily Islamic rituals.
• Useful for Shia Muslims: The app is specifically appreciated by Shia Muslims for providing resources aligned with their traditions.

Prioritized Action Recommendations

High Priority:

1. Fix Prayer Time Accuracy: Investigate and resolve the reported inaccuracies in prayer times, particularly in North America. Implement a robust location-based prayer time calculation method and allow users to manually adjust times if needed.
2. Resolve Incomplete Adhan on iOS: Address the issue of the Adhan cutting off on iOS devices. Ensure that the full Adhan plays even when the app is in the background or the screen is locked.
3. Address App Crashes: Identify and fix the reported app crashes, especially in the Quran section and during group recitations. Thoroughly test new releases on different devices and iOS versions.

Medium Priority:

4. Improve UI/UX for iPads: Optimize the app's UI for iPad devices, addressing scaling issues and layout problems.
5. Expand Quran Reciter Options: Add more Quran reciters, including popular ones like Abdul Basit and Aba Dhar Al-Ghafari.
6. Implement Offline Quran Audio: Allow users to download Quran audio for offline listening.
7. Add Sahifa Sajjadiya: Include Sahifa Sajjadiya in the app's library of Duas and supplications.
8. Improve Notification Reliability: Ensure that Adhan notifications are reliable and consistently deliver sound alerts.

Low Priority:

9. Add a Dark Theme Option for the Widget: Provide the option to change the color of the widget for better visibility in dark mode.
10. Improve Quran Navigation: Consider adding a single-page view option for Quran reading.
11. Include Tafsir (Quranic Exegesis): Add a reliable Tafsir (Quranic exegesis) to the app.
12. Address UI issues related to bookmarking and font size adjustments.

Opportunities for Startup Ideas

• Personalized Islamic Content Platform: A platform that curates and delivers personalized Islamic content based on user preferences (e.g., specific scholars, reciters, madhabs).
• Smart Prayer Rug: An intelligent prayer rug that automatically detects Qibla direction and provides real-time guidance for prayer movements.
• Islamic Educational Games: Educational games that teach children about Islamic history, rituals, and values in an engaging way.
• AI-Powered Dua Generator: An app that generates personalized Duas based on user's specific needs and circumstances.
• Islamic Social Network: A social network focused on connecting Muslims and facilitating discussions about Islamic topics.

Trends and Observations

• Strong Shia Muslim User Base: The reviews indicate a strong user base among Shia Muslims. The app's features and content seem to cater specifically to this community.
• Language Preference: Most reviews are in Arabic, suggesting a primary user base in Arabic-speaking countries.
• iOS-Specific Issues: A significant number of issues are reported specifically by iOS users, indicating a need for more focused testing and optimization on this platform.
• Recurring Feature Requests: The requests for more Quran reciters, Sahifa Sajjadiya, and full Adhan on iOS have been recurring for some time, suggesting that these features are highly desired by users.
• Positive Sentiment: The overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, indicating that the app provides significant value to its users despite its flaws.

Conclusion

Haqibat Elmomen is a valuable app for Muslims, particularly those of the Shia faith, offering a comprehensive suite of features for daily Islamic practices. While the app enjoys high user satisfaction, several key issues need to be addressed to improve the user experience and retain users. Prioritizing bug fixes, addressing prayer time accuracy, and resolving the Adhan issue on iOS devices are critical. Implementing frequently requested features, such as more Quran reciters and Sahifa Sajjadiya, would further enhance the app's appeal and value.

Overall Recommendation: Address the high-priority issues immediately, focus on iOS optimization, and prioritize feature requests based on frequency and impact. Continue to engage with users and solicit feedback to ensure that the app meets their evolving needs.

Original App Link

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/haqibat-elmomen/id935681991?uo=2