Customer Reviews (500)

Johnlimix01 • 2025-03-26T19:31:18-07:00

Johnlimix01

mz9520 • 2025-03-26T05:24:31-07:00

Didn’t work

Rich Little Missy • 2025-03-25T07:04:02-07:00

I love you so much is the best thing ever you can literally do everything put your own stuff on there and you can wait online or off-line. I can’t wait for it

Summary of Key Insights

Melodista is a generally well-received offline music player for iOS, praised for its customizability, ease of use, and ability to play music without internet. A significant number of users appreciate its functionality as an alternative to subscription-based music services. However, the app suffers from several persistent bugs, particularly related to editing song metadata (album art, title, artist), which negatively impacts the user experience. Many users also complain about ads, despite the app's claim of being ad-free, and the occasional crashing. The app has a positive overall sentiment, but the recurring technical issues and unmet feature requests suggest areas for improvement.

Key Strengths:

  • Offline playback capability
  • Customizability (app icon, background, song metadata)
  • Ease of use
  • Simple playlist system

Key Weaknesses:

  • Bugs related to editing song metadata (album art, title, artist)
  • App crashes and instability
  • Unexpected ads, even with Pro subscription
  • Lack of certain features (equalizer, Siri compatibility, widget)

Overall Sentiment: Positive, with a significant number of users expressing strong satisfaction.

Quantitative Metrics:

  • Overall Rating: Based on score distribution, approximately 4.0 stars (estimated).
  • Score Distribution:
    • 5-star: 44.4% (222/500)
    • 4-star: 19.6% (98/500)
    • 3-star: 12.8% (64/500)
    • 2-star: 5.6% (28/500)
    • 1-star: 17.6% (88/500)

Data & Methodology Overview

  • Data Sample Size: 500 reviews
  • Time Frame: The reviews appear to be collected over an extended period, likely several months or years, based on the variety of iOS versions and reported issues.
  • Analysis Methods: The analysis involved manual review and categorization of user feedback to identify recurring themes, sentiment, and feature requests. Keyword extraction was used to determine the frequency of specific issues.

Key User Pain Points

  • Editing Song Metadata: The most frequently reported issue is the inability to edit song metadata (album art, title, artist). Users report that changes either don't save, revert to the original values, or corrupt the audio file.
  • App Crashes: Many users experience app crashes, especially when scrolling through large libraries, adding songs to playlists, or after updates.
  • Ads: Despite the app's claim of being ad-free or offering an ad-free Pro subscription, users report encountering frequent and intrusive ads. Some Pro users even report ads after purchasing the subscription.
  • Search Functionality: Some users report that the search bar is unresponsive or doesn't return results.
  • Shuffle Issues: Users mention problems with the shuffle feature, such as only playing one song or not advancing to the next song automatically.
  • Playlist Management: Users find it difficult to manage playlists, particularly when adding or deleting multiple songs.
  • Importing Issues: Some users have trouble importing music from various sources like Telegram or cloud services.
  • Background Playback Issues: Users report issues with background playback, where the music stops when the app is minimized or the screen is locked.
  • Album Art Problems: Problems with identifying, saving, or consistently displaying album art.

Frequently Requested Features

  • Equalizer: Many users request an equalizer to customize the sound.
  • Siri Compatibility: Users want to be able to control the app with Siri voice commands.
  • Widgets: Users request widgets for the lock screen and home screen for easier access.
  • Crossfade: Some users suggest adding a crossfade feature for smoother transitions between songs.
  • Sort Options in Playlists: Users want the ability to sort songs within playlists (e.g., alphabetically, by date added).
  • Cloud Integration (Google Drive): Some users specifically request Google Drive integration.
  • Lyrics Support: Users want to be able to add and view lyrics within the app.
  • CarPlay Support: Users are requesting CarPlay integration for in-vehicle use.
  • Multi-Select for Playlist Management: The ability to select multiple songs for deletion or adding to playlists.
  • Direct Song Download: The ability to download songs directly within the app, rather than importing from other sources.
  • Playlist Sharing: Ability to share entire playlists with friends.

Strengths and Positive Aspects

  • Offline Playback: The ability to play music offline is a major draw for users.
  • Customization: Users appreciate the ability to customize the app icon, background, and song metadata.
  • Ease of Use: Many users find the app easy to use and navigate.
  • Simple Interface: The app's simplicity and straightforward interface are appreciated.
  • File Management: The app allows for managing, copying, moving, renaming, and transferring files.
  • Alternative to Subscription Services: Many users see the app as a good alternative to paid streaming services.
  • Fast and Efficient: Some users praise the app for being fast and efficient.
  • Frequent Updates: The promise of updates every two weeks is seen as a positive.
  • Customizable Icon and Background The ability to change the app icon and background is a frequently cited positive.

Prioritized Action Recommendations

High Priority:

  • Fix Metadata Editing Bugs: Address the persistent bugs related to editing song metadata (album art, title, artist). This is the most frequently reported issue and has a significant impact on the user experience.
  • Address App Crashes: Investigate and resolve the app crashes, especially those related to large libraries, playlist management, and scrolling.
  • Resolve Ad Issues: Ensure that the app adheres to its ad-free claims, especially for Pro subscribers. Investigate and eliminate any unintended ad displays.
  • Improve Search Functionality: Fix the reported issues with the search bar being unresponsive or not returning results.

Medium Priority:

  • Implement Shuffle Enhancements: Address the issues with the shuffle feature, such as only playing one song or not advancing automatically.
  • Enhance Playlist Management: Implement multi-select functionality for adding and deleting songs from playlists.
  • Implement requested features: Equalizer, Siri compatibility, Widgets, Crossfade, Sort options in playlists.
  • Address Background Playback Issues: Resolve issues with background playback.

Low Priority:

  • Cloud Integration (Google Drive): Implement Google Drive integration.
  • Lyrics Support: Add support for adding and viewing lyrics within the app.
  • CarPlay Support: Add CarPlay integration.
  • Direct Song Download: Allow song downloads within the app.
  • Playlist Sharing: Add ability to share playlists.
  • UI Refresh: Consider a UI refresh to align with current iOS design standards.

Opportunities for Startup Ideas

  • Intelligent Metadata Management Tool: A separate app or service that automatically identifies and corrects song metadata, including album art, based on audio fingerprinting. Could integrate with Melodista or other music players.
  • Offline Music Community Platform: A platform where users can share and discover offline music files, playlists, and metadata.
  • Music Player Customization Suite: An app that provides advanced customization options for music players, including themes, visualizations, and EQ presets.
  • Playlist Migration Tool: An app that allows users to easily migrate playlists between different music services and local music files.

Trends and Observations

  • Language Preferences: The majority of reviews are in English, but there are also reviews in Persian, Spanish, Russian, and other languages, indicating a global user base.
  • Bug Reports over Time: The metadata editing bug has been reported consistently over a long period, suggesting that it has not been effectively addressed in past updates.
  • Ad Complaints: Complaints about ads have increased recently, suggesting a potential change in ad implementation.
  • Feature Requests: Feature requests have remained relatively consistent over time, with equalizer, Siri compatibility, and widgets being the most popular.
  • iOS Updates: Some issues seem to be triggered by iOS updates, indicating a need for better compatibility testing.

Conclusion

Melodista has the potential to be a top-tier offline music player for iOS. Users are generally satisfied with its core functionality, customizability, and ease of use. However, the app suffers from persistent bugs, particularly related to metadata editing and app stability, which negatively impact the user experience. By addressing these issues and implementing frequently requested features, the developer can significantly improve user satisfaction and solidify Melodista's position in the market. A strong recommendation is to focus on fixing the metadata editing bugs and app crashes as the highest priority.

Original App Link

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/melodista-music-offline-player/id1293175325?uo=2