Customer Reviews (500)

Fujimura77 • 2025-03-27T00:06:28-07:00

Please fix the crashes. I really love playing this game but the game crashes a lot on my phone. Please fix this.

Bullsilver813 • 2025-03-25T04:34:54-07:00

Ever since I saw the ad for this game on YouTube, I’ve been hooked ever since; although, there’s a few things that drives me nuts! 1: I’m currently playing on the Sayap Bangau server and sometimes it just logs me out of the game at the WORST parts!!! Fix that please!!! 2: I NEED the name of the song that is currently playing on the main screen when you are playing, Thx!!

Kevin polish • 2025-03-22T20:45:40-07:00

So long and boaring

Summary of Key Insights

Echocalypse: Scarlet Covenant is a gacha game with a strong anime aesthetic that receives mixed reviews. While many users praise the art style, character design, and generous early-game rewards, a significant portion report frequent crashes, data loss, and concerns about the game's pay-to-win aspects. There's a clear divide between users who enjoy the waifu collection and those frustrated by technical issues and monetization strategies. The overall sentiment leans positive due to the large number of 5-star reviews, but the negative reviews highlight critical issues that need addressing.

  • Overall Rating: App Store rating is not explicitly stated but can be inferred to be fairly high based on review score distribution.
  • Score Distribution: 5-star: 62.8%, 4-star: 13.6%, 3-star: 7.6%, 2-star: 3.4%, 1-star: 12.6%

Key Strengths:

  • Attractive art style and character design ("waifus")
  • Engaging storyline (for some users)
  • Generous early-game rewards/pulls
  • Large roster of characters

Key Weaknesses:

  • Frequent crashes and instability
  • Data loss/account issues
  • Pay-to-win mechanics and aggressive monetization
  • Forced tutorials
  • Confusing UI and too much clutter on the screen
  • Bugs and glitches

Data & Methodology Overview

  • Data Sample Size: 500 reviews
  • Time Frame: Reviews are likely from the recent past, given the version number (2.2.83) and the presence of a crossover event with Trails to Azure.
  • Analysis Methods: Manual review and categorization of user feedback to identify recurring themes, sentiment, and feature requests. Keyword extraction was used to identify common issues and positive aspects.

Key User Pain Points

  • Crashing: The most frequently reported issue is the game crashing, often mid-battle, leading to lost progress and frustration. This is a major impediment to enjoyment and playability.
  • Data Loss/Account Issues: Several users reported losing their accounts or game progress, sometimes after spending money. This is a critical issue that erodes trust in the game.
  • Pay-to-Win Mechanics: Many users feel the game is heavily monetized and requires significant spending to progress, especially in PvP. This creates an uneven playing field and discourages free-to-play users.
  • Forced Tutorials: The unskippable and lengthy tutorial is a common complaint, especially for experienced gacha players.
  • Bugs and Glitches: Several users reported specific bugs, such as characters not appearing after being pulled or issues with claiming rewards.
  • Leveling Walls: Some users find the progression to slow down significantly after a certain level, requiring excessive grinding or spending.

Frequently Requested Features

  • More Ways to Obtain Premium Currency/Summon Tickets: Players want more opportunities to acquire characters without spending money.
  • Skippable Tutorials: Users want the option to skip the tutorial, especially on subsequent playthroughs or accounts.
  • Better Healing Characters: Players feel that healing characters are underpowered.
  • Account Recovery Options: Improved account recovery processes are needed to address data loss issues.
  • More Characters/Content: Some players desire additional characters, storylines, and game modes.
  • Ability to Control Characters in Battle: Some players would like more control over character actions in battle, rather than relying solely on auto-battle.
  • Less Clutter/Better UI: A cleaner and more intuitive user interface is desired.

Strengths and Positive Aspects

  • Art Style and Character Design: The anime-style art and attractive female characters are a major draw for many users.
  • Engaging Storyline: Some users find the story to be interesting and well-written.
  • Generous Early-Game Rewards: The game is often praised for being generous with free pulls and resources in the beginning.
  • Variety of Content: Users appreciate the multiple game modes and activities available.
  • Good Voice Acting: Some reviewers mentioned the quality of the voice acting.

Prioritized Action Recommendations

High Priority:

  • Fix Crashing Issues: Investigate and resolve the frequent crashing problems. This is the most critical issue affecting playability.
  • Address Data Loss/Account Issues: Implement robust account recovery mechanisms and address the root causes of data loss.
  • Rebalance Monetization: Review and adjust the monetization strategy to be less aggressive and more friendly to free-to-play users.

Medium Priority:

  • Implement Tutorial Skip: Allow players to skip the tutorial after their first playthrough.
  • Improve Healing Character Effectiveness: Rebalance healing characters to make them more viable.
  • Address Bug Fixes: Resolve reported bugs and glitches promptly.
  • Optimize Performance: Improve the game's performance on a wider range of devices.

Low Priority:

  • Improve UI Clutter: Reduce clutter and improve the user interface for better navigation.
  • Add More Manual Control in Battle: Provide options for players to manually target enemies or select skills.
  • Increase Character Variety (Beyond "Waifus"): Consider adding more diverse character designs.

Opportunities for Startup Ideas

  • Gacha Game Crash Prevention Service: A service that monitors gacha games for crashes and automatically restores player progress.
  • AI-Powered Gacha Game Optimizer: An AI tool that analyzes a player's roster and recommends optimal team compositions and strategies.
  • Gacha Game Fairness Rating System: A rating system that evaluates gacha games based on their monetization practices and free-to-play friendliness.
  • Gacha Game Account Recovery Service: A service specializing in helping players recover lost or compromised gacha game accounts.

Trends and Observations

  • Language Preferences: The majority of reviews are in English, but there are also reviews in Chinese, Russian, and other languages.
  • "Waifu" Focus: A significant number of reviews explicitly mention the attractive female characters ("waifus") as a primary reason for playing the game.
  • Crossover Event Impact: The recent crossover event with Trails to Azure is mentioned, indicating its relevance to current players.
  • Negative Sentiment Amplification: Negative reviews often express strong frustration and disappointment, suggesting a high impact on user perception.
  • Positive Sentiment Prompting: Some reviews indicate that the game prompted them to write a review after a good pull.

Conclusion

Echocalypse: Scarlet Covenant has the potential to be a successful gacha game, but it needs to address critical technical issues and monetization concerns. The strong art style and character design are significant assets, but they are undermined by crashes, data loss, and a perceived pay-to-win environment. Prioritizing stability, account security, and a more balanced monetization strategy is essential for long-term success.

Overall Recommendation: Focus on fixing the core technical issues and re-evaluating the monetization strategy before investing further in content expansion. A more stable and user-friendly experience will lead to better player retention and a more positive reputation.

Original App Link

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/echocalypse-scarlet-covenant/id6446244975?uo=2