Customer Reviews (500)

smilinken • 2025-03-22T17:49:13-07:00

This a great game. You do not have to pay to advance and can be played quickly

MkJ0721 • 2025-03-17T18:37:59-07:00

镰刀没有收获加成，没有琉特琴。太影响体验了

Greyhounds gh • 2025-03-11T22:44:24-07:00

This game is just kind of garbage and based on luck. The RNG doesn’t make sense and you just have to get lucky to win even with builds that are able to synergies well. It’s unfortunate because it could be fun if the RNG wasn’t so bad with items, stats, and damage.

Summary of Key Insights

Brotato: Premium is generally well-received, with a high percentage of 5-star reviews indicating a strong player base. The game's addictive gameplay loop, variety of builds, and suitability for short play sessions are its main strengths. However, significant issues exist with bugs, inconsistencies between the mobile and PC versions, cloud save problems, and intrusive review requests that negatively impact user experience. Many users are requesting feature parity with the PC version and DLC content. There are also reports about potential difficulty balancing issues on mobile, with some claiming it is much harder than the PC version. The negative reviews often cite specific bugs and missing features, suggesting that addressing these would greatly improve user satisfaction. A notable concern is the perception of unfairness for premium users, with some claiming the free version offers more content or benefits.

Key Strengths:

  • Addictive and engaging gameplay loop
  • Variety of characters, weapons, and builds
  • Suitable for short, mobile play sessions
  • Good value for the price (no ads)

Key Weaknesses:

  • Significant bugs affecting gameplay (melee knockback, elite difficulty, item functionality)
  • Inconsistencies and missing features compared to the PC version
  • Cloud save issues
  • Intrusive review requests
  • Difficulty balancing problems
  • DLC purchase inconsistencies across iOS devices
  • Perception that the free version offers more content

Overall Sentiment: Positive, but with notable concerns.

Quantitative Metrics:

  • Overall Rating: Approximately 4.5 stars (based on score distribution).
  • 5-Star Reviews: 73.4% (367/500)
  • 4-Star Reviews: 9.4% (47/500)
  • 3-Star Reviews: 4% (20/500)
  • 2-Star Reviews: 2.6% (13/500)
  • 1-Star Reviews: 10.6% (53/500)

Data & Methodology Overview

  • Data Sample Size: 500 reviews
  • Time Frame: Not explicitly stated, but reviews appear to be from the past several months, likely spanning from the game's release or a recent update.
  • Analysis Methods:
    • Sentiment analysis (identifying positive, negative, and neutral opinions)
    • Keyword extraction (identifying frequently mentioned topics and issues)
    • Manual review and categorization of comments

Key User Pain Points

  • Bugs:
    • Melee weapon knockback bug (knocking enemies towards the player instead of away) - Very common and game-breaking.
    • Elite enemy difficulty, especially Butcher/Chef on wave 11 (attacks too fast, overtuned damage) - Common complaint.
    • Item functionality issues (e.g., Snake item not spreading burning, Knockback not working, Bandana not working correctly) - Impacts build variety and viability.
    • Attack Speed stat incorrectly affecting movement speed.
    • Freezing during gameplay
  • Inconsistencies with PC Version:
    • Missing characters, items, and features (e.g., retry wave) - Frequent complaint from players familiar with the PC version.
    • Different difficulty scaling - Mobile version perceived as harder.
  • Cloud Save Issues:
    • Cloud saves not working, leading to lost progress - A significant issue for users with multiple devices.
  • Intrusive Review Requests:
    • Frequent pop-ups asking for reviews, disrupting gameplay - Highly annoying to users.
  • DLC Purchase Issues:
    • DLC not transferring across iOS devices (iPhone and iPad) - Frustrating for users who purchased DLC on one device.
  • Gamepad/Controller Support:
    • Limited controller support (Backbone, Xbox controller) - Only analog stick working, missing button mapping.
  • Lack of Feature Parity with Free Version:
    • Some users feel the paid version has less content than the free version.
  • Tower Placement:
    • Towers with the wrench weapon are placed randomly on the edges of the map.

Frequently Requested Features

  • Feature Parity with PC Version:
    • More characters, items, and features from the PC version (including DLC content)
    • Mouse and keyboard support (especially for iPad)
  • Improved Cloud Save Functionality:
    • Reliable cloud saves and cross-device synchronization
  • Full Controller Support:
    • Complete gamepad support with customizable button mapping
  • Option to Disable Review Requests:
    • A setting to turn off the pop-up asking for reviews
  • Restore Purchase Button:
    • An easier way to restore DLC purchases on multiple devices
  • Local Multiplayer Support
  • Manual Aiming Option:
    • A way to manually aim weapons instead of auto-firing.

Strengths and Positive Aspects

  • Addictive Gameplay: The core gameplay loop is highly praised as addictive and engaging.
  • Variety and Replayability: The wide range of characters, weapons, and builds offers high replayability.
  • Suitable for Mobile: The game is well-suited for short, mobile play sessions.
  • Good Value: Users appreciate the lack of ads in the premium version and consider it a good value for the price.
  • Humor: The game's humor and quirky style are appealing.
  • Accessibility Options: The game includes accessibility options to tweak difficulty.

Prioritized Action Recommendations

High Priority:

  • Fix Game-Breaking Bugs:
    • Address the melee knockback bug immediately. This is a widespread issue severely impacting gameplay.
    • Rebalance elite enemy difficulty, especially the Butcher/Chef on wave 11.
    • Fix item functionality issues (Snake, Knockback, Bandana, Burning, Reflex).
  • Implement Reliable Cloud Saves:
    • Resolve cloud save issues to ensure seamless progress synchronization across devices.
  • Address Review Request Intrusiveness:
    • Provide an option to disable review requests or significantly reduce their frequency.
  • Fix DLC Purchase Issues
    • Make sure DLC purchases are properly synced across all iOS devices

Medium Priority:

  • Improve Controller Support:
    • Implement full gamepad support with customizable button mapping.
  • Incorporate Missing PC Features:
    • Add more characters, items, and features from the PC version, prioritizing the most requested ones.
  • Address Difficulty Balancing:
    • Investigate and address concerns about difficulty scaling, potentially offering adjustable difficulty settings.
  • Improve Tower Placement:
    • Ensure towers are being placed near the player character instead of on the edges of the map.

Low Priority:

  • UI Improvements:
    • Enhance the UI, especially on iPad, to display more information (as seen in the PC version).
  • Manual Aiming Option:
    • Add manual aiming option
  • Local Multiplayer Support:
    • Implement local multiplayer support.
  • Tilt Controls:
    • Add tilt controls

Opportunities for Startup Ideas

  • Mobile Game Optimization Service: A service that analyzes PC games and optimizes their control schemes and difficulty for mobile platforms, ensuring a smooth and balanced experience.
  • Cross-Platform Save Synchronization Tool: A tool that enables seamless save synchronization across different gaming platforms (PC, mobile, consoles) for games that lack native support.
  • Intrusive Ad/Review Request Blocker: A system-level tool for mobile devices that blocks intrusive in-app ads and review requests, providing a cleaner and more enjoyable gaming experience.

Trends and Observations

  • Language Preferences: A significant number of reviews are written in Chinese, suggesting a strong player base in China.
  • Cross-Platform Players: Many users have played the game on PC or consoles and are comparing the mobile version to those experiences.
  • Bug Reports Increase After Updates: Some reviews indicate that new bugs appear after major version updates, suggesting a need for more thorough testing.
  • Passion for the Game: Despite the issues, many users express a strong love for the game and a desire for it to be improved.

Conclusion

Brotato: Premium has a solid foundation with its addictive gameplay and unique style. However, addressing the identified bugs, inconsistencies with the PC version, and user experience issues is crucial for maintaining a positive reputation and attracting new players. Prioritizing bug fixes and feature parity, while also addressing intrusive review requests, will significantly improve user satisfaction. The developers should focus on delivering a polished and consistent experience across all platforms.

Overall Recommendation: Address the high-priority issues immediately to improve the core gameplay experience and user satisfaction. Focus on feature parity with the PC version and continued updates to retain existing players and attract new ones.

Original App Link

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/brotato-premium/id1668755109?uo=2