Customer Reviews (120)

LouisvilleCards12 • 2025-03-23T20:38:25-07:00

Fix the rules to be like the original game, for example: you are not allowed to guess the same room two turns in a row, yet in this game you can. It affects strategy and takes the challenge out of the game. Fix the rules.

CaitxD • 2025-03-17T07:54:08-07:00

I’m so upset I always play as Scarlett because I look just like her! I love her!!!! They replaced her with a whole new character!!!!!! Bring back Scarlett!!!! There are no blonde women in the character selection now!!! If you want more diversity ADD MORE DONT REPLACE I’m so upset I want my five dollars back

Catziaggie • 2025-03-16T13:20:02-07:00

My auto clue sheet option is not working on my iPad Pro anymore. It used to have an arrow that I could use to bring the clue sheet closer to make notes and make it disappear. That is no longer available. I really love this game and it’s very frustrating. It works on my iPhone but I play on the iPad. I actually reached out for this issue on Discord. I got a response that it’s being looked into. I can see that I’m not the only one having this issue either. Please fix this issue as I prepaid for all additional boards etc. I am really disappointed.

Summary of Key Insights

This analysis of 120 app reviews for "Clue (2024)" reveals a generally positive sentiment, with many users enjoying the updated graphics, new game modes, and overall faithfulness to the original board game. However, several recurring issues significantly detract from the user experience, particularly regarding the clue sheet size on iPads, bugs related to game progress and customization, and the perceived lack of challenge in single-player mode. There's also a desire for more content and a "pass and play" local multiplayer mode. The replacement of Miss Scarlett as a character is a significant point of contention for some users.

  • Overall Sentiment: Positive, but with significant concerns.
  • Key Strengths: Updated graphics, new game modes (Ultimate Detective, Clue Cards), faithful adaptation of the board game, and engaging case files.
  • Key Weaknesses: Small clue sheet on iPads, bugs affecting game progress and customization, AI difficulty in single-player mode, lack of "pass and play" mode, and complaints about character changes.
  • Quantitative Metrics:
    • Overall Rating: The weighted average score can be calculated from the distribution. (1*16 + 2*6 + 3*21 + 4*25 + 5*52)/120 = 3.725. So, approximately 3.7 stars.
    • Score Distribution: 5-star (43.3%), 4-star (20.8%), 3-star (17.5%), 2-star (5%), 1-star (13.3%)

Data & Methodology Overview

  • Data Sample Size: 120 app reviews
  • Time Frame: All reviews are assumed to be recent, based on the "Clue (2024)" title.
  • Analysis Methods:
    • Sentiment Analysis: Categorizing reviews as positive, negative, or neutral based on language used.
    • Keyword Extraction: Identifying frequently mentioned words and phrases to pinpoint common themes and issues.
    • Frequency Analysis: Counting the occurrences of specific issues and feature requests.

Key User Pain Points

  • Small Clue Sheet on iPad: Many users, especially those with iPads or visual impairments, find the clue sheet text too small and the zoom feature (previously available) missing or broken. This makes the game unplayable for some.
  • Bugs Affecting Game Progress and Customization: Several users report bugs that prevent them from progressing in the game, collecting rewards, or properly customizing their experience (e.g., dice selection not saving, tasks not registering as completed).
  • AI Difficulty in Single-Player Mode: Some users find the AI too easy, even on the "hard" difficulty setting, making the single-player experience less engaging.
  • Lack of "Pass and Play" Mode: A significant number of users request a local multiplayer mode where players can pass the device around, similar to other Marmalade Game Studio titles like Monopoly and Game of Life 2.
  • Character Changes/Diversity Issues: The replacement of Miss Scarlett with a new character is a major complaint for some users, who feel it reduces diversity in the game.
  • Multiplayer Issues: Some users report difficulty finding online multiplayer games or experiencing freezing issues when other players quit.
  • Secret Passage Glitches: Some users report the secret passages not working, preventing the completion of certain achievements.
  • Cheating AI: One user reports that the AI cheats in single player mode to prevent the user from winning.
  • Inability to change username: Several users report that they cannot change the default username assigned to them.

Frequently Requested Features

  • "Pass and Play" Local Multiplayer Mode: This is a highly requested feature for playing with friends and family in person.
  • Larger Font/Zoom Options: Users with visual impairments need options for larger text and better zoom functionality, especially on iPads.
  • More Content (New Crime Scenes/Characters): Many users express a desire for more locations, characters, and case files to keep the game fresh.
  • Offline Play Options: An option to play offline without requiring an internet connection.
  • Option to skip animations: Some users find the dice rolling animation too long and tedious.
  • Chinese Language Support: One user requests Chinese language support.

Strengths and Positive Aspects

  • Updated Graphics and Animation: Users consistently praise the improved visuals and animations, calling them realistic and immersive.
  • New Game Modes (Ultimate Detective, Clue Cards): The new game modes offer a refreshing twist on the classic Clue formula and provide more variety in gameplay.
  • Faithful Adaptation of the Board Game: Many users appreciate that the app stays true to the original rules and spirit of Clue.
  • Engaging Case Files: The case files add depth to the characters and storylines, making the game more engaging.
  • No Ads: Users appreciate the absence of disruptive advertisements.
  • Realistic Gameplay: The updated version is seen as more realistic than previous versions.

Prioritized Action Recommendations

High Priority:

  • Fix Clue Sheet Size/Zoom Issues on iPads: This is a critical issue affecting a significant portion of users. Implement a zoom feature or adjustable font size to make the clue sheet readable on all devices.
  • Address Bugs Affecting Game Progress and Customization: Investigate and resolve the reported bugs that prevent users from collecting rewards, completing tasks, and customizing their experience.
  • Implement "Pass and Play" Local Multiplayer Mode: This highly requested feature would significantly enhance the game's appeal and cater to users who prefer playing with others in person.

Medium Priority:

  • Adjust AI Difficulty in Single-Player Mode: Make the AI more challenging, especially on the "hard" difficulty setting, to provide a more engaging single-player experience.
  • Provide More Content (New Crime Scenes/Characters): Regularly release new locations, characters, and case files to keep the game fresh and retain player interest.
  • Investigate and Fix Multiplayer Issues: Address the reported difficulties in finding online games and the freezing issues caused by players quitting.
  • Address the Secret Passage Glitches: Investigate and fix the glitches that prevent secret passages from working.

Low Priority:

  • Consider Addressing Character Diversity Concerns: While not universally criticized, consider adding more diverse characters without removing existing ones to address concerns about representation.
  • Add Option to Skip Animations: Provide an option to skip animations for users who find them tedious.
  • Implement Chinese Language Support: Add Chinese language support to cater to a wider audience.
  • Allow username changes: Allow users to customize their username within the game.

Opportunities for Startup Ideas

  • AI-Powered Clue Assistant: Develop an AI assistant that can analyze player notes and provide strategic suggestions during gameplay.
  • Community-Created Content Platform: Create a platform where users can design and share their own Clue scenarios, characters, and case files.
  • Subscription Service for New Content: Offer a subscription service that provides regular access to new crime scenes, characters, and features.
  • Augmented Reality Clue Game: Develop an AR version of Clue that overlays the game board and characters onto the real world.

Trends and Observations

  • Focus on iPad User Experience: A significant number of complaints relate specifically to the iPad version of the app, suggesting a need for targeted optimization.
  • Desire for Increased Difficulty: Many users feel the game is too easy, even on the highest difficulty setting, indicating a need for more challenging AI and gameplay mechanics.
  • Value Placed on Content Updates: Users are eager for new content and are willing to pay for it, but they also expect regular updates and bug fixes.

Conclusion

"Clue (2024)" is a well-received adaptation of the classic board game, but several key issues detract from the overall user experience. Addressing the problems with the clue sheet size, bugs, and AI difficulty should be prioritized. Implementing "pass and play" multiplayer and providing more content would further enhance the game's appeal and ensure long-term player engagement. Overall, focusing on bug fixes and improving the user experience, especially for iPad users, is crucial for maintaining a positive reputation and driving future success.

Original App Link

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/clue-2024/id6447357776?uo=2