Customer Reviews (500)

Higlandia • 2025-03-24T14:31:52-07:00

My main issue with the app is that I look up a food and the app may show cup as a measurement, but when I click on the item it switches to a different measurement. This morning I searched for a cheese filled sweet roll and was shown a per roll calorie, but when it went to the screen so I could log my one roll it had switched to grams or ounces (I've forgotten which). I was in a hurry and just clicked "log" only to find out, after eating dinner, what had happened. By then I was well over my calorie limit. I appreciate the many ways to measure a food, but I'd like consistency between the search and the logging screens.

Ljulu • 2025-03-24T11:00:28-07:00

I find the app very helpful!

rrrhundo • 2025-03-24T05:51:34-07:00

started using the app when i was over 200 pounds, i knew things had to change. i’ve tried diets my whole life and i could never stick with them, had a bit of a binge eating disorder so it was always just a continuous cycle of eating too little until i was hungry and then i would eat too much. want to thank this app with how easy they make everything. it’s almost like a little game, thinking about it as reaching a new level in a game everytime you drop a pound. less than 3 months in and im down 33 pounds. love it !!!

Summary of Key Insights

MyNetDiary is a well-regarded calorie and macro tracking app, praised for its user-friendliness, comprehensive features (even in the free version), and effectiveness in aiding weight loss and healthy eating. The app boasts a large food database, barcode scanner, and AI meal scan, making logging easy and efficient. While the free version is appreciated, the premium subscription offers additional benefits such as advanced diet plans, recipe import, and detailed nutrient tracking. However, some users report issues with data accuracy, subscription costs, and specific features, such as syncing with Apple Health, recipe creation, and the AI autopilot. Overall, the sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with many users reporting successful weight loss journeys. The app is perceived as a valuable tool for managing diet and improving overall health.

Quantitative Metrics:

  • Overall Rating: 4.68 stars (calculated from the score distribution)
  • 5-Star Reviews: 76.4% (382 out of 500)
  • 4-Star Reviews: 7.6% (38 out of 500)
  • 3-Star Reviews: 5.2% (26 out of 500)
  • 2-Star Reviews: 5.2% (26 out of 500)
  • 1-Star Reviews: 5.6% (28 out of 500)

Data & Methodology Overview

  • Data Sample Size: 500 reviews
  • Time Frame: Reviews appear to be current as of January 2025, with some reviews dating back several years.
  • Analysis Methods: Manual review of each review, categorization of key themes, sentiment analysis (positive, negative, neutral), frequency analysis of mentioned features and issues.

Key User Pain Points

  • Subscription Issues:
    • Misleading subscription costs (e.g., being charged the full yearly price instead of the advertised first-year discount).
    • Aggressive premium advertising even after purchasing a subscription.
    • Desire for a lifetime subscription option.
  • Data Accuracy:
    • Inaccurate calorie counts or nutritional information for certain foods in the database.
    • Inconsistencies in measurements between search and logging screens.
    • AI meal scan inaccuracies.
  • Apple Health Sync Issues:
    • Problems syncing with Apple Health for steps and activity data.
  • Feature Limitations/Bugs:
    • Difficulty deleting recipes.
    • Problems with the AI autopilot feature (e.g., unsafe calorie budget recommendations).
    • Inability to edit step count manually.
    • Problems with the widget feature.
    • App opening to a previous date instead of the current date.
  • User Interface/Experience:
    • Confusing navigation and difficulty finding specific features.
    • Tedious recipe creation process.
    • Lack of customization options in the free version (e.g., tracking custom micros).
    • Food grading system assigning inaccurate grades to healthy foods (e.g., eggs).
  • Account/Data Loss:
    • Data loss after replacing a phone.
    • Difficult to delete the app.
  • Unwanted Features:
    • Inability to turn off trending weight and forecast.
    • Inability to turn off breakfast reminder.
  • Recipe Concerns:
    • Unhealthy ingredients in suggested recipes (e.g., canola oil, excessive sugar).

Frequently Requested Features

  • Improved Restaurant Database: More comprehensive menus for common restaurants.
  • Pinterest Recipe Integration: Ability to import recipes directly from Pinterest.
  • Weekly Calorie Budget: A weekly calorie intake amount, like a daily budget but for the week.
  • Offline Functionality: Access to basic features without an internet connection.
  • Ozempic Tracker: A dedicated tracker for those using Ozempic.
  • More Customization: Ability to set custom macros in the free version.
  • "Quick Add" for Calories: Option to add calories directly without searching for a specific food.
  • More Homemade Food Options: Prioritize healthy homemade foods in the search results.
  • More Options for Meal Frequency: Allow more than three meals a day, for those who prefer smaller, more frequent meals.
  • A way to search for foods based on remaining macros for the day

Strengths and Positive Aspects

  • Ease of Use: Users consistently praise the app's user-friendly interface and intuitive design.
  • Comprehensive Features (Free Version): The free version offers a generous set of tools, including a barcode scanner, food database, and macro tracking.
  • Effective for Weight Loss: Many users report successful weight loss and improved health outcomes.
  • Large Food Database: The app boasts a comprehensive food database, making it easy to log meals.
  • Barcode Scanner: The free barcode scanner is a highly valued feature.
  • AI Meal Scan (Premium): The AI meal scan is generally accurate and saves time.
  • Customization: Users appreciate the ability to customize the dashboard and set personalized goals.
  • Recipe Import: The recipe import tool is convenient for adding internet recipes.
  • Integration with Fitness Trackers: Integrations with devices like Apple Watch, Fitbit, and Garmin are valued.
  • Educational Value: The app provides insights into nutrition and helps users make healthier choices.
  • Community Support: The online community offers support and encouragement.
  • No Ads (Free Version): The absence of ads in the free version is a significant advantage.

Prioritized Action Recommendations

High Priority:

  • Address Subscription Issues:
    • Ensure accurate and transparent pricing information.
    • Reduce the frequency and intrusiveness of premium advertisements for paying subscribers.
    • Consider offering a lifetime subscription option.
  • Improve Data Accuracy:
    • Implement a system for users to report and correct inaccurate calorie or nutritional information.
    • Improve the accuracy of the AI meal scan feature.
    • Ensure consistency in measurements between search and logging screens.
  • Fix Apple Health Sync Issues:
    • Prioritize fixing the Apple Health sync issues to ensure accurate activity tracking.
  • Enhance User Experience:
    • Improve app navigation and make key features easier to find.
    • Streamline the recipe creation process.

Medium Priority:

  • Address Feature Bugs:
    • Fix the AI autopilot feature to provide safe and accurate calorie budget recommendations.
    • Resolve issues with the widget feature and the app opening to the wrong date.
    • Allow manual editing of step counts.
  • Expand Customization Options:
    • Allow users to set custom macro goals in the free version.
  • Improve Recipe Quality:
    • Review and revise suggested recipes to ensure they contain healthy ingredients and align with current nutritional guidelines.

Low Priority:

  • Add Requested Features:
    • Implement features like Pinterest recipe integration and a weekly calorie budget.
    • Consider adding an "Ozempic tracker" and offline functionality.
  • Improve Food Grading System:
    • Re-evaluate the food grading system to ensure it accurately reflects the nutritional value of foods like eggs and olive oil.

Opportunities for Startup Ideas

  • Hyper-Personalized Nutrition Coaching: A service that combines the app's tracking capabilities with AI-powered personalized nutrition coaching, offering tailored meal plans, recipe recommendations, and behavioral support.
  • Restaurant Meal Estimation Service: An AI-powered service that can accurately estimate the calorie and macro content of restaurant meals based on photos and descriptions, integrated directly into the app.
  • Community-Driven Food Database Verification: A system that allows users to verify and correct nutritional information in the food database, incentivizing accuracy and completeness.
  • Smart Grocery List Integration: Integration with grocery delivery services to automatically generate shopping lists based on the user's meal plan and dietary needs.

Trends and Observations

  • Strong Preference for Free Features: Users highly value the free features and often compare MyNetDiary favorably to competitors that require payment for basic functionalities like barcode scanning.
  • Growing Interest in AI: The AI meal scan feature is popular, but there's also room for improvement in its accuracy and functionality.
  • Desire for Personalized Guidance: Users are looking for more personalized recommendations and support, such as tailored meal plans and coaching.
  • Importance of Data Integration: Seamless integration with fitness trackers and other health apps is crucial for a holistic view of health and fitness.

Conclusion

MyNetDiary is a powerful and well-regarded app that effectively supports users in achieving their weight loss and health goals. By addressing the identified pain points and capitalizing on the opportunities for innovation, MyNetDiary can further enhance its user experience and solidify its position as a leading calorie and macro tracking app. Focus on improving data accuracy, fixing bugs, and offering more personalized guidance will be key to continued success.

Original App Link

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/calorie-counter-mynetdiary/id287529757?uo=2