Customer Reviews (137)

FionaG514 • 2025-03-21T11:37:03-07:00

I love Everdell! I just wish they would add more expansions as it gets really repetitive pretty quickly. Also, it would be great if they would add a button to confirm you would like to proceed before playing a card or meeple.

JimTheComicBookNerd • 2025-03-11T16:45:44-07:00

App shows loading indicator to go to game results, but never shows the results.

Loosepg • 2025-03-01T18:38:42-07:00

This app is very smooth and interacts very seamlessly locally and online. Great color and visuals. We have the analog version of the board game and this is like the arena equivalent to MTG. Works like a charm. There are a couple quirks with some of the cards if you don’t play them in the exact sequence they would go ideally (stacking, occupying, free cards, etc.) but it’s a once in several playthroughs type of thing. Also, it can be a bit small and hard to read if it’s on your phone. Several of us downloaded to tablets because our phones couldn’t handle the small text and images. It’s a 4/5 for me. But a STRONG 4. We’ll not get bored of this anytime soon.

Summary of Key Insights

The Everdell app is generally well-received, with users praising its faithful adaptation of the board game, beautiful graphics, and smooth gameplay. However, several key pain points consistently emerge, particularly regarding the user interface (UI) and the lack of an "undo" button. Many users are eager for expansions and additional features like choosing their starting critter. While the overall sentiment is positive, these issues significantly impact user experience and should be addressed.

Key Strengths: Faithful adaptation, beautiful graphics, smooth gameplay, engaging challenges. Key Weaknesses: UI issues (accidental placements, small text), lack of "undo" button, missing expansions. Overall Sentiment: Positive Overall Rating: Approximately 4.2 out of 5 stars based on review distribution. Score Distribution: 5-star (52.5%), 4-star (24.1%), 3-star (8%), 2-star (14.6%), 1-star (8%).

Data & Methodology Overview

Data Sample Size: 137 reviews Time Frame: Not explicitly stated, but assumed to be since the app's release. Analysis Methods: Sentiment analysis (qualitative assessment of positive, negative, and neutral comments), keyword extraction (identifying frequently mentioned terms and issues).

Key User Pain Points

  • Accidental Placements: Many users report accidentally placing workers or cards due to the drag-and-drop mechanic and sensitive touch controls, especially on phones. This often leads to ruined games and frustration.
  • Lack of "Undo" Button: The absence of an "undo" button is a recurring and highly criticized issue. Users frequently request this feature to correct accidental placements and card plays.
  • Small Text and UI Issues: Some users find the text and icons too small, especially on phone screens, making it difficult to read card descriptions and navigate the interface. Cluttered screen layout on smaller devices contributes to this problem.
  • Bugs and Glitches: Several users report bugs that can halt gameplay, such as the game freezing, incorrect card interactions, and issues with AI opponents.
  • Online Play Issues: Freezing and timing out during online play are reported by some users.

Frequently Requested Features

  • Expansions: The most frequently requested feature is the addition of expansions (e.g., Pearlbrook, Spirecrest, Bellfaire, New Leaf).
  • "Undo" Button: As mentioned above, this is a crucial feature for improving user experience.
  • Character Selection: Many users want the ability to choose their starting critter.
  • Improved Zoom: Better zoom functionality for cards and the meadow, especially on phones.
  • Chinese Language Support: A significant number of users requested Chinese language support.
  • Confirmation Button: A confirmation button before placing a worker or playing a card to prevent accidental actions.
  • Vision Pro Support: Several users requested Vision Pro compatibility.
  • Card Arrangement: The ability to rearrange cards in hand.
  • Statistics Tracking: Statistics on games won/lost, cards played, etc.
  • Improved Online Play Options: The ability to play online with friends and AI. Push notifications for online play when it's your turn.

Strengths and Positive Aspects

  • Faithful Adaptation: Users appreciate that the app closely resembles the tabletop game.
  • Beautiful Graphics and Animations: The game's visuals and animations are consistently praised for their quality and charm.
  • Smooth Gameplay: Many users find the gameplay to be smooth and effortless.
  • Helpful Tutorial: The tutorial is considered helpful for learning the game.
  • Engaging Challenges: The solo challenges provide a fun and varied gameplay experience.
  • Cross-Platform Multiplayer: The ability to play against others on different platforms is appreciated.
  • AI Play: AI opponents provide a way to play solo.
  • Good for Learning the Game: The app is a great way to learn the rules of Everdell.

Prioritized Action Recommendations

High Priority:

  1. Implement an "Undo" Button: This is the most critical issue and should be addressed immediately.
  2. Fix Accidental Placement Issues: Revise the drag-and-drop mechanic or add a confirmation button to prevent accidental worker and card placements.
  3. Address Bugs and Glitches: Prioritize bug fixes to resolve gameplay interruptions.
  4. Improve Text Legibility and UI: Increase text size and optimize the UI for smaller screens.

Medium Priority:

  1. Add Expansions: Implement popular expansions to increase replayability and user engagement.
  2. Implement Character Selection: Allow players to choose their starting critter.
  3. Improve Online Play Stability: Address freezing and timing out issues in online multiplayer mode.
  4. Add Chinese Language Support: Implement Chinese language support to cater to a broader audience.

Low Priority:

  1. Improve Zoom Functionality: Enhance zoom capabilities for cards and the meadow.
  2. Add Vision Pro Support: Add support for Apple Vision Pro.
  3. Implement Card Arrangement: Allow players to rearrange cards in hand.
  4. Add Statistics Tracking: Track games won/lost, cards played, etc.
  5. Improve Online Play Options: Enhance online play with friends and AI.

Opportunities for Startup Ideas

  • Board Game App UI/UX Enhancement Toolkit: A toolkit for board game app developers focused on mitigating common UI/UX issues like accidental placements, small text, and lack of undo features.
  • Expansion Pack Subscription Service: A subscription service offering access to a library of board game app expansions, providing a recurring revenue stream for developers and a cost-effective way for players to access new content.
  • AI-Powered Board Game App Bug Detection: A service that uses AI to automatically identify and report bugs in board game apps, helping developers improve app stability and user experience.

Trends and Observations

  • Consistent Demand for Expansions: The desire for expansions is a recurring theme, indicating a high level of engagement with the base game.
  • Phone vs. Tablet Experience: Users playing on phones experience more UI-related issues than those on tablets.
  • Language Preference: There is a clear demand for Chinese language support.

Conclusion

The Everdell app is a successful adaptation of a popular board game, but several key issues negatively impact user experience. Addressing these issues, particularly the lack of an "undo" button and accidental placement problems, should be the top priority. Implementing expansions and adding requested features will further enhance the app's appeal and increase user engagement. Overall, the app has a strong foundation, and targeted improvements can elevate it to an even higher level.

Original App Link

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/everdell/id1580626436?uo=2