Summary of Key Insights
The app "That's My Seat - Logic Puzzle" generally receives positive feedback, with many users finding it fun, entertaining, and engaging. The core gameplay loop and puzzle design are well-received. However, the overwhelming consensus is that the app is plagued by excessive advertising, which significantly detracts from the user experience. Several users also report issues with malware-like ads and glitches that can be detrimental to device security. The recent introduction of a "ticket" system, limiting playtime, is also a point of contention for some users. There are also some complaints about the lack of story content and that certain clues are confusing or lead to forced guesswork. The overall sentiment is positive but significantly hampered by the prevalence of ads and some technical issues.
- Overall Rating: High (based on score distribution) but trending downward due to ads and ticket system.
- Key Strengths: Engaging gameplay, fun puzzle design, entertaining stories, no internet required.
- Key Weaknesses: Excessive advertising, intrusive/malware ads, glitch issues, limited "lives" (ticket system), lack of story content after a certain level.
- Sentiment: Mostly positive, but with significant negative sentiment towards ads and technical issues.
- Score Distribution: 5-star (66%), 4-star (14.2%), 3-star (7.6%), 2-star (3.6%), 1-star (8.6%)
Data & Methodology Overview
- Data Sample Size: 500 reviews
- Time Frame: Not explicitly stated, but based on context, reviews appear to span at least several months, with mentions of recent updates.
- Analysis Methods:
- Sentiment Analysis: Manual assessment of overall positive, negative, or neutral tones within each review.
- Keyword Extraction: Identification of frequently used words and phrases to pinpoint common themes (e.g., "ads," "fun," "tickets," "glitch").
- Frequency Analysis: Counting the occurrences of specific issues or feature requests to determine their prevalence.
Key User Pain Points
- Excessive Advertising: The most significant complaint. Users report ads after every level, retry, or even button press. This severely disrupts gameplay and leads to frustration.
- Intrusive/Malware Ads: A subset of users report encountering ads that redirect them to scam websites claiming to scan for viruses, raising significant security concerns.
- Limited "Lives" (Ticket System): The recent introduction of a ticket system that limits playtime is unpopular. Users dislike having to wait or pay to continue playing.
- Glitches and Bugs: Some users have reported glitches that cause the game to crash, freeze, or reset progress.
- Inappropriate Ads: Some users mention seeing ads that are inappropriate for children, such as those for THC products or sexually suggestive content.
- Confusing Clues: Some users find clues to be vague, poorly written, or contradictory, leading to frustration and forced guesswork.
- Repetitive Content: Some users are reporting that the levels become repetitive after a certain point.
- Lack of Story Content: Many users express a desire for more stories and levels after completing the existing ones.
Frequently Requested Features
- More Levels/Stories: Users consistently request more content to extend the game's lifespan.
- More "Lives" (Hearts/Tickets): Users want more opportunities to play without waiting or paying.
- Option to Skip Levels: Some users want the ability to skip particularly difficult or frustrating levels.
- Celebrity Theme: One user suggested a celebrity-based theme.
- Time Limit Option: One user suggested an option for timed levels.
Strengths and Positive Aspects
- Engaging Gameplay: Many users find the core puzzle-solving mechanic to be fun and addictive.
- Brain Teasing: Users appreciate that the game challenges their minds and provides a mental workout.
- Relaxing: Some users find the game relaxing and a good way to unwind.
- No Internet Required: The ability to play offline is a significant advantage for users on the go.
- Fun and Hilarious Stories: Many users enjoy the stories and find them to be humorous and entertaining.
- Good for Kids: Some parents find the game suitable for children, helping them develop logic and reasoning skills.
- Unique Concept: Some users say that there is nothing else like it in the app store.
- True to Ads: Many users appreciate that the gameplay is accurately represented in the advertisements.
Prioritized Action Recommendations
- High Priority:
- Address Excessive Advertising: Implement a less intrusive ad strategy (e.g., fewer ads, shorter ads, optional rewarded video ads).
- Remove Malware Ads: Immediately identify and remove any ads that redirect to scam websites or pose a security risk.
- Re-evaluate Ticket System: Consider removing the ticket system altogether or making it less restrictive (e.g., faster recharge times, more starting tickets).
- Fix Glitches and Bugs: Prioritize bug fixes to address crashes, freezes, and progress loss.
- Medium Priority:
- Improve Clue Clarity: Review and revise clues to ensure they are clear, concise, and unambiguous.
- Increase Content Variety: Add more levels, stories, and characters to prevent the game from becoming repetitive.
- Add a Reporting Mechanism: Implement a way for users to report inappropriate ads or offensive content.
- Low Priority:
- Consider Feature Requests: Explore adding requested features like level skipping or themed content based on user demand and development resources.
- Address Grammatical Errors: Review the text within the game and stories to correct grammatical errors and typos.
Opportunities for Startup Ideas
- Ad Network Screening Service: A service that vets mobile ad networks for malicious or misleading ads, offering developers a safer way to monetize their apps.
- Logic Puzzle Game with User-Generated Content: A platform where users can create and share their own logic puzzles, providing a constantly expanding library of content.
- Mobile Game with Customizable Difficulty: A game that dynamically adjusts the difficulty based on the player's skill level, ensuring a consistently challenging and engaging experience.
Trends and Observations
- Language Preferences: The reviews are predominantly in English, but there are also some in other languages, suggesting a global user base.
- Shift in Sentiment: The sentiment appears to have declined over time, with more recent reviews expressing frustration with ads and the ticket system.
- User Demographics: The game appeals to a wide range of ages, from children to adults.
- Repetitive Language: Many reviews, particularly the 5-star ones, contain similar phrases and expressions, which could indicate bot activity or incentivized reviews.
Conclusion
"That's My Seat - Logic Puzzle" has a solid foundation with its engaging gameplay and entertaining stories. However, the app's success is being undermined by excessive and potentially harmful advertising practices. Addressing these issues, particularly the ad problem and the ticket system, is crucial for retaining existing users and attracting new ones. By focusing on improving the user experience and adding more content, the developer can unlock the full potential of this promising logic puzzle game. A strong recommendation is to prioritize ad reduction and malware ad removal.
Original App Link
https://apps.apple.com/us/app/thats-my-seat-logic-puzzle/id6532601126?uo=2