Customer Reviews (100)

Jacob Crumpacker • 2025-03-24T13:56:40.640Z

I really love this app but I can't have two phones on one account. It's only my wife and I and we share the account, recording our plays with each other and separate. But for some reason it only allows for up to date information on one device. edit: I have now lost all the information on almost a thousand games entered. shows the game was played on the date but lost who played and who won. this app is getting worse. I suggest reverting to an earlier version that isn't so screwed up.

Matt Edwards • 2025-03-18T10:46:27.423Z

This is probably my most used app.

Francisco M Monroig • 2025-03-17T16:32:52.194Z

Must have app!

Summary of Key Insights

Board Game Stats (BG Stats) is a highly regarded app among board game enthusiasts for tracking their collections, plays, and scores. The app boasts comprehensive statistics, BoardGameGeek (BGG) integration, and regular updates. While the core functionality is well-received, users frequently express concerns about the user interface (UI) being outdated and unintuitive. Another common pain point revolves around the in-app purchase model, with some users finding the need to pay extra for features like advanced statistics and cloud backup to be excessive. Despite these drawbacks, the app's robust features and active development garner significant praise, making it a popular choice for serious board gamers.

Overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, reflected in the high percentage of 5-star reviews. However, the negative reviews highlight critical areas needing attention.

  • Overall Rating: High (estimated at ~4.6/5 based on score distribution)
  • Score Distribution:
    • 5-star: 80%
    • 4-star: 6%
    • 3-star: 3%
    • 2-star: 4%
    • 1-star: 7%

Data & Methodology Overview

  • Data Sample Size: 100 reviews
  • Time Frame: Not explicitly stated, but assumed to be recent based on the version number (5.6.1) and mentions of recent updates.
  • Analysis Methods: Primarily qualitative analysis focusing on identifying recurring themes, sentiment expressed in the reviews, and feature requests. Quantitative analysis included calculating the percentage of reviews within each star rating category.

Key User Pain Points

  • Outdated and Unintuitive UI/UX: This is a recurring complaint. Users find the interface frustrating, complicated, and lacking modern design principles (e.g., Material Design). This negatively impacts ease of use and discoverability of features.
  • In-App Purchase Model: Many users express dissatisfaction with the need to pay extra for features that they consider essential, such as advanced statistics, cloud sync, and tagging. This is perceived as "dodgy" and can deter potential users.
  • Lack of Cloud Sync Without Subscription: The need for a subscription to sync data across devices is a major drawback for some users, especially those who own multiple devices or share accounts.
  • Occasional Syncing Issues: Some users report problems with syncing data with BGG or other services, leading to data loss or inconsistencies.
  • Crashes and Bugs: A few users report crashes and bugs that disrupt their workflow, especially when logging or opening plays.
  • Limited Multi-Account/Group Functionality: Some users want the ability to track separate stats for different gaming groups (e.g., friends vs. family).

Frequently Requested Features

  • Improved UI/UX: A modern, intuitive, and visually appealing interface is the most frequently requested improvement.
  • Custom Scoresheets: Several users request the ability to create custom scoresheets within the app.
  • Web Version: A web version of the app for accessing data on a computer is a highly desired feature.
  • Automatic Cloud Backup: Users want automatic cloud backup without requiring a subscription. A one-time purchase option for backup is suggested.
  • Social Features: Some users request social features to compare stats, libraries, and wishlists with friends.
  • Game Weight Tracking: The ability to track the weight or complexity of games.
  • Per-Round Stats: For games played over multiple rounds, users want stats that reflect per-round averages.
  • Photo Storage on Location Details: The ability to store photos on location details.
  • Alternative OS compatibility for add-ons Users report losing access to add-ons when switching to a different OS.

Strengths and Positive Aspects

  • Comprehensive Feature Set: The app offers a wide range of features for tracking collections, plays, and scores.
  • Detailed Statistics: Users appreciate the extensive statistics and graphs provided by the app.
  • BGG Integration: The seamless integration with BGG is a major selling point.
  • Active Development and Regular Updates: Users praise the developer for actively maintaining and improving the app.
  • Score Card Feature: The score card feature is particularly popular for simplifying score calculation in complex games.
  • Cost Per Play Tracking: The cost-per-play feature motivates users to play their games more often.
  • Responsiveness of Developers: Some users have reported that the developers are responsive to feedback and quickly implement requested features.
  • Import Functionality: The ability to import plays from BGG, Yucata, and BGA is valued.

Prioritized Action Recommendations

  • High Priority:
    • UI/UX Overhaul: Invest in a significant UI/UX redesign to modernize the interface and improve ease of use. Focus on intuitive navigation and visual appeal.
    • Address Cloud Sync Concerns: Re-evaluate the cloud sync subscription model. Consider offering a one-time purchase option or including basic cloud sync in the base app.
    • Bug Fixes and Stability: Prioritize fixing reported crashes and bugs to improve app stability.
  • Medium Priority:
    • Custom Scoresheets: Implement the ability for users to create custom scoresheets.
    • Web Version: Explore the feasibility of developing a web version of the app.
    • Improve Syncing Reliability: Investigate and resolve reported syncing issues with BGG and other services.
  • Low Priority:
    • Social Features: Consider adding social features to enhance user engagement.
    • Game Weight Tracking: Implement the ability to track game weight or complexity.
    • Per-Round Stats: Add per-round stats for games played over multiple rounds.
    • Photo Storage on Location Details: Implement the ability to store photos on location details.

Opportunities for Startup Ideas

  • Board Game Scoring Platform as a Service (PaaS): A dedicated platform that provides scoring logic and UI components for board game developers.
  • AI-Powered Board Game Recommendation Engine: An app that analyzes user play data and preferences to recommend new board games.
  • Social Board Game Platform: A platform that combines game tracking with social networking features, allowing users to connect, share stats, and organize game nights.

Trends and Observations

  • Strong Positive Sentiment: The majority of users are highly satisfied with the app.
  • Focus on Functionality: Users primarily value the app's robust features and statistics.
  • Growing Demand for Modern UI: There's a clear trend towards users expecting a modern and intuitive UI.
  • Price Sensitivity: Users are sensitive to the cost of in-app purchases, particularly for features they consider essential.

Conclusion

Board Game Stats is a valuable tool for board game enthusiasts, offering a comprehensive feature set and strong BGG integration. However, the outdated UI and in-app purchase model are significant pain points. By addressing these issues and prioritizing user-requested features, the developer can further enhance the app's appeal and solidify its position as the leading board game tracking solution. A strong recommendation is to prioritize a UI/UX overhaul to improve the user experience and reconsider the pricing model for cloud sync.

Original App Link

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=nl.eerko.boardgamestats