Customer Reviews (100)

Savita Verma • 2025-03-25T02:48:47.231Z

nice experience

Anaphaella • 2025-03-24T23:51:58.744Z

the game is good I'm getting better at this

Dalilah Sandoval • 2025-03-24T22:42:37.666Z

This is a really good game.You guys should try it

Summary of Key Insights

  • Piano Star is generally well-received, with a high percentage of 5-star reviews indicating a positive user experience.
  • The main weakness is the excessive number of ads, which significantly detracts from gameplay enjoyment.
  • Users appreciate the fun gameplay, variety of songs, and stress-relieving qualities of the app.
  • There's a demand for more diverse music genres and artists, particularly K-pop and specific popular artists.
  • Overall sentiment is positive, but the ad issue is a major concern that needs addressing.

Quantitative Metrics:

  • Overall Rating: High (based on review distribution)
  • 5-Star Reviews: 74%
  • 4-Star Reviews: 13%
  • 3-Star Reviews: 3%
  • 2-Star Reviews: 3%
  • 1-Star Reviews: 7%

Data & Methodology Overview

  • Data Sample Size: 100 reviews
  • Time Frame: Not specified, assuming recent reviews available on the Google Play Store.
  • Analysis Methods: Sentiment analysis (manual), keyword extraction (manual), frequency analysis of mentioned issues and requests.

Key User Pain Points

  • Excessive Ads: This is the most significant and frequently mentioned issue. Users complain about ads appearing after every song, after failing, and even when trying to access free content. This significantly disrupts the flow of gameplay and leads to frustration.
  • Ad Frequency Impact: The high frequency of ads makes the game feel more like an ad platform than a game, discouraging users from paying to remove them.
  • Ad Exit Issues: Some users report difficulty closing ads, further exacerbating the frustration.
  • Off-Beat Songs: At least one user has pointed out that a song is slightly off-beat.
  • Song Selection Issues: Some users are disappointed that certain songs or artists (e.g., Zendaya, Taylor Swift, specific K-pop groups) are not available.
  • Download Issues: One user reported the game not downloading.
  • Curse Words in Songs: One user reported that the app played unedited songs with curse words despite being rated E10.
  • Speed Issues After Extra Live Ad: One user reported that if they watch an ad to get an extra live, the song starts at the same speed, which is difficult to keep up with.

Frequently Requested Features

  • More Diverse Music Selection: Users specifically request more K-pop songs, phonk music, songs in different languages, and songs by specific artists like Zendaya and Taylor Swift.
  • "Import Tool" Improvements: One user mentioned an import tool, implying this is a feature that they enjoy and potentially others would as well.
  • Slower Difficulty Settings: One user requested to keep the stars on 3 because they can't go that fast, suggesting a need for easier difficulty levels.

Strengths and Positive Aspects

  • Fun and Addictive Gameplay: Many users describe the game as fun, addictive, and a great time killer.
  • Stress Relief: Some users find the game relaxing and helpful for stress relief.
  • Good Music Selection: Users appreciate the variety of songs available and the fact that new songs are added weekly.
  • Easy to Learn: The game is described as easy to learn and play.
  • Offline Mode: The availability of offline mode is appreciated.
  • Free to Play: Users like that the game is free and that coins are easy to earn.
  • Helps with Typing Speed: At least one user found that the game helps with typing speed.

Prioritized Action Recommendations

High Priority:

  • Reduce Ad Frequency: Significantly reduce the number of ads displayed. Consider implementing a less intrusive ad model (e.g., ads only between multiple games or shorter, less frequent ads).
  • Fix Ad Exit Issues: Ensure that users can easily close ads without frustration.
  • Address Song Timing Issues: Investigate and fix the reported issue of songs being off-beat.

Medium Priority:

  • Expand Music Library: Add more songs from requested genres and artists, particularly K-pop, phonk, and popular artists like Zendaya and Taylor Swift.
  • Implement Difficulty Levels: Ensure a range of difficulty levels to cater to different skill levels.
  • Content Filtering: Ensure that songs played are appropriate for the E10 rating by filtering out songs with curse words.
  • Fix issue with extra lives: Address the issue of the song starting at the same speed after watching an ad for extra lives.

Low Priority:

  • Investigate Download Issues: Address the reported download issues.
  • Improve Import Tool: If an import tool exists, ensure it functions properly and is user-friendly.

Opportunities for Startup Ideas

  • Ad-Free Subscription Service: Offer a reasonably priced subscription option to remove ads and potentially unlock exclusive content. This could be a more appealing alternative to the current ad-heavy experience.
  • Customizable Music Library: Allow users to create personalized playlists or import their own music to play in the game.
  • Community Features: Integrate social features such as leaderboards, challenges, and the ability to share scores with friends.

Trends and Observations

  • Ad Complaints Dominate Negative Feedback: The overwhelming majority of negative reviews and lower ratings are directly related to the frequency and intrusiveness of ads.
  • Positive Sentiment Despite Ad Issues: Many users express enjoyment of the game despite their frustration with ads, suggesting a strong core gameplay experience.
  • Desire for Specific Music Genres: There's a clear demand for more K-pop, phonk, and other specific music genres and artists.
  • Language Preference: The reviews are primarily in English, with one review in Hindi indicating a potential opportunity to cater to a wider audience by adding language support.

Conclusion

Piano Star has a strong foundation with engaging gameplay and a good selection of songs. However, the excessive number of ads is a critical issue that needs to be addressed to improve the user experience and prevent negative reviews. By reducing ad frequency, expanding the music library, and addressing other user-reported issues, Piano Star can reach its full potential and achieve even greater success. It is recommended to prioritize ad reduction and content filtering to align with the stated E10 rating.

Original App Link

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.piano.tiles.music.game.circles.dancing.beat.magictiles